A recording of this presentation is available HERE.
Thank you to our Pharmacy Supervisor, Omi Patel, PharmD, for a super interesting presentation this week on Penicillin Allergy. Please do watch the presentation if you have a chance! If not, my notes:
The label penicillin (PCN) allergy is WIDELY used on patient charts. And more often than not, is untrue. Look at the numbers:
And this label, is NOT harmless!
- it can lead to the use of less effective therapies (e.g. cephalosporins are much more effective against MSSA than vancomycin)
- it can lead to more antibiotic resistance and increased risk for c. diff infection
- it can prolong length of stay in the hospital and increase hospital costs (more expensive and less effective abx)
- is can cause paradoxically MORE toxicity (e.g. a septic PCN-allergic patient will get more powerful, less effective, and more problematic drug combinations)
To review, PCN drug reactions fall into four main categories, labeled Type 1( IgE and mast cell mediated), II (cytotoxic and IgG and IgM mediated), III (immune complex, IgG and IgM and complement) and IV (T-cell mediated delayed reactions, which can be benign or severe).
Of note, Type IV (delayed rash) can be everything from totally benign to life threatening (SJS, DRESS). This is important because a patient with Type IVb rash can still be a candidate for re-labeling, whereas a patient with life-thretening Type IVd rash should never receive PCN again!
Immediate/IgE reactions generally occur very quickly, often within the first 1 hour (and almost always within the first 6 hours) of exposure. Also urticaria/hives that lasts longer than a day is generally not life-threatening. An hives reaction that occurs within 1 hour of the 1st dose, lasting less than 1 day (1:1:1 rule) is more likely to be a TRUE IgE allergy.Patients with a history suggestive of SJS, DRESS, AIN, recent anaphylaxis and/or angioedema should not receive PCN again. Patients with intolerance (n/v/headache) a delayed benign rash (maculopapular, no organ involvement), family history only ("I was told as a child"), or a remote untreated mild reaction (>5-10 years ago) should be considered for a challenge or retesting.
I like these 6 questions for every allergy label:
It's the R chain
Cross-reactivity between PCN allergy AND cephalosporins depend entirely on the R chain (not the shared beta lactam ring). This means that even with a proven PCN allergy, many cephalosporins can be safely used. Omi pointed us to this chart from Northwestern, a link can be found HERE. This can help clinicians and pharmacists safety select a cephalosporin for PCN allergic patients.
PEN-FAST
Omi also introduced us to the PEN-FAST score, which we will be rolling out at SSRRH in the next few months to help de-label patients with PCN allergies. The PEN-FAST score is a way to assess which patients can be safely tested with a direct amoxicillin test (rather than skin testing) as a means to de-label. (of note, regardless of PEN-FAST score, if patients has hx of SJS/TENS/DRESS, they are NEVER eligible for an amoxicillin challenge test). In patients with a PEN-FAST score of 1-2, direct oral challenge (with amoxicillin) is safe and effective.
Patients with a score of 4-5 should NOT be tested with an oral challenge or graded challenge
In a graded challenge, you start with super low dose and see if there is a reaction (if there is, you confirm the label and stop). In a desensitization protocol, patients are treated THROUGH their reaction. Of note, in a study done at a Sutter hospital, they found that MOST PCN allergic (37/41) patients are not truly allergic and could tolerated an oral test dose of amoxillin, which then allowed us to de-label them! Some did have mild reactions (e.g. maculopapular rash), but this does not mean they have a true life-threatening PCN allergy.